“There was something very special, but it wasn’t inside Josie. It was in the people who loved her.” — Kazuo Ishiguro, Klara and the Sun
Spoilers ahead.
I’m glad I read Klara and the Sun before seeing the film. It helps me understand why some viewers might have felt disappointed by Taika Waititi’s adaptation. Those of us who are fans of realism, sadness, and bitter truths about ourselves may not have wanted a story about love that warms our hearts and fills us with hope.
Halfway through the film, I wanted to stand up and say, “Taika, you didn’t understand what this book is about. I demand justice!” In my review of the novel, I wrote about how easily we decide someone or something matters—until we no longer need them. Klara is Josie’s friend, confidante, and caretaker. Josie’s mother even considers whether a robot could continue her daughter’s life. And when Josie gets better and grows up, Klara is left alone among old machines. From that perspective, it’s hard not to feel that the film sidesteps what hurt most in the book.
Ishiguro asks whether “artificial” is really enough to justify treating someone that way. Does something have to prove it has a soul before we decide it shouldn’t be treated like a piece of worn-out equipment? The film doesn’t leave this theme out entirely. In the store, the manager tells Klara: “Just remember everything you’ve learned, and maybe they’ll love you like a family member—or the family dog.” It sounds kind, but there’s a little sting to it. Klara has to learn how to earn a place in someone’s life, as if her worth depends on how well she performs her role.
The robots also know that if their human does something illegal or stupid, they’re supposed to take the blame. That’s their role. They know, too, that they can be returned: there’s a fourteen-day return period. Klara lives with that knowledge, and when things start to go wrong, she goes down to the storage room and hits her box, as if to say she doesn’t want to go back.
That scene made me think of relationships where we desperately want to be accepted, yet feel as if we’re on trial—even though nobody says so out loud. We keep having to prove that we’re worth keeping.
I also appreciate that the filmmakers kept the scene where the children and parents are meant to socialise. Klara sees other robots being mistreated and beaten by their owners. She watches in fear and confusion. It’s a striking image of hypocrisy: people can accept cruelty toward robots that they would never accept toward one another.
The film, though, is largely about what love means and how Klara discovers the light that love and hope can bring. So I don’t see it as a faithful adaptation of the book. It takes the characters and important themes from the novel, then arranges them around its own, gentler idea.
The film also offers something the book couldn’t: it lets us see the world through Klara’s eyes. When she first leaves Josie’s house and steps into a wheat field, everything starts to pixelate. She can’t immediately bring the scene into focus or make sense of what she sees. She needs time to recognise the space and piece it together. It’s a lovely detail: we don’t just hear that Klara perceives the world differently; for a moment, we see through her eyes.
The film also reveals the cause of Josie’s illness. Her mother, Chrissie, wanted to give her daughter a better future, so she chose to have her “lifted.” Now she lives with the fear that Josie will die just as her first daughter did—and that a decision made out of love may have led to the loss of her second child. She says that “grief breaks you,” and can then drive you to do things you wouldn’t normally do. That doesn’t excuse her actions, but it helps us understand how love, ambition, and fear knot together in desperation.
The knot tightens most when Josie discovers that her mother is preparing a “shell”: a replica of her that Klara would be expected to imitate if Josie died. The Ghost in the Shell connection isn’t just a decorative reference. A body can be recreated, but is looking like someone enough to preserve their identity? Josie doesn’t want her mother to spend the present preparing a copy of her. She asks whether it might be better to focus on spending as much time together as they can while they still have it. Faced with loss, we can try to preserve someone’s image—or simply be with them while they’re still here.
In one of the most moving scenes, Chrissie, consumed by guilt and fear, tries to drown Klara. Klara says, “I’m sorry, but it won’t work. I don’t breathe.” There’s something awful and disarming about it: she doesn’t accuse Chrissie; she simply tells her the truth. Even then, she tries to help Josie’s mother, though she herself has become the target of Chrissie’s despair. She tries to understand her and “see her as a person” ;).
Klara grows attached to the whole family—not just Josie, but her mother and the housekeeper, too. She feels responsible for helping Josie get better. She negotiates with the Sun and destroys the robotic tractor because she believes it pollutes the air and blocks the Sun, taking away Josie’s chance to recover. She risks losing some of her own abilities in the process. Klara can believe, love, and give something of herself for someone else.
When she asks what the Cootings Machine is, someone tells her it’s a machine like her, only worse. Klara doesn’t see it that way. The machine blocks the Sun, so it doesn’t matter to her that they’re both machines. Klara has a goal: Josie’s recovery. This contrast brings me back to the book’s question: what makes us treat one machine as an object and another as someone who can be hurt?
When someone asks me whether AI will be the end of us, I say that if it is, it’ll be because of our own stupidity and the goals we give it. If we asked AI to look after the environment, the most logical first step might be to get rid of all of us in the name of the planet. Klara does something similar on a small scale: she has one goal, and she destroys another machine without hesitation to achieve it. We root for her because her goal is good. But the mechanism is exactly the same.
Still, the ending warmed my black heart. At the company, they look after Klara to the very end and ask her what she wants. She chooses to spend her final days in the yard full of old machines, happy among friends. But we don’t know whether the robots from the store and the manager are really there, or whether Josie really visits her. As the image begins to change, we can’t tell whether Klara sees what she longs for or whether those visits actually happened. The film leaves us wanting to believe that they did—that love can change our perspective, even when we can’t be sure what really happened.
I left the cinema moved, but also angry at the people who left Klara behind. The ending touched me. At the same time, the more beautifully the film shows Klara’s final days, the more clearly I see who left her there. The book still hurts more.